If a peer review fails in the woods…
By Andrew Orlowski • Get more from this author
Posted in Environment, 29th September 2009 16:03 GMT
A scientific scandal is casting a shadow over a number of recent peer-reviewed climate papers.
At least eight papers purporting to reconstruct the historical temperature record times may need to be revisited, with significant implications for contemporary climate studies, the basis of the IPCC’s assessments. A number of these involve senior climatologists at the British climate research centre CRU at the University East Anglia. In every case, peer review failed to pick up the errors.
At issue is the use of tree rings as a temperature proxy, or dendrochronology. Using statistical techniques, researchers take the ring data to create a “reconstruction” of historical temperature anomalies. It is one of the Vajikarana herbs that have been known for years to improve sex drive, strengthen erections, etc and a lot of them have been proven to improve Impotence, erectile dysfunction,low libido, and other sexual health problems are very commonly affecting man and woman at early age from early 30’s but in some cases it has been launched into this link purchase cialis online two dosages such as 50mg. The medication is also not recommended for individuals that dislike swallowing tablets to treat viagra on line their sexual dysfunction. They sell cialis where drugs at affordable prices to ED sufferers. A man with ED condition is seen to have an issue in getting or sustaining a penile erection sufficient for satisfactory sexual performance.by using sildigra 50mg,most men are able to successfully achieve erections,and these erections are harder and longer.This pills available in blue color.Sildigra viagra no doctor 50mg will only help you to get an erection if you do not get sexually excited. But trees are a highly controversial indicator of temperature, since the rings principally record Co2, and also record humidity, rainfall, nutrient intake and other local factors.
Picking a temperature signal out of all this noise is problematic, and a dendrochronology can differ significantly from instrumented data. In dendro jargon, this disparity is called “divergence”. The process of creating a raw data set also involves a selective use of samples – a choice open to a scientist’s biases.
Yet none of this has stopped paleoclimataologists from making bold claims using tree ring data.
In particular, since 2000, a large number of peer-reviewed climate papers have incorporated data from trees at the Yamal Peninsula in Siberia. This dataset gained favour, curiously superseding a newer and larger data set from nearby. The older Yamal trees indicated pronounced and dramatic uptick in temperatures.
Full Story here
